Category Archives: Rants

Mild Rant Over Cover Songs on YouTube

I love listening to cover songs. I mostly find them on YouTube. I find that the best covers are done when the artists bring something that the original songs don’t have.

When the covering artist adds another layer to the original, it’s awesome. So when I try to find covers on YouTube and all I see are 18 year olds with a guitar doing whatever pop song is popular for the month, I get really disappointed. Not to fault them for practicing, it’s just that they are not unique. (They can be faulted for shitty sound quality, musical skill, etc.)

I admit, this song is very over-played by now, but I think for good reason.

Too Close by Alex Clare is just an enjoyable damn song. His voice a strong and passionate, and the wub-wubs actually add to the song. There are no good covers of the song. It’s almost nothing but young dudes and dudettes with a guitar. (And the song is so easy to play: the same five chords over and over. See: House of the Rising Sun.) Oddly enough, the only good cover I’ve seen is actually done by Alex Clare!

And then what’s worse is when the song is already different than everything else, no one can take it even one step further.

I’m talking about Your Woman by White Town. Here’s an interesting song. A male vocalist, singing in low key, but the lyrics are from a woman’s point of view. It’s a one-sided conversation and she’s talking to a man whom she regrets to tell that she can’t be his woman.

It’s not ironic, but rather subversive. It’s almost insincere. The words come off as disingenuous and overall I don’t know what to make of the tone of the song.

I say all that, because of this cover of it.

It’s done sincerely by a woman, accompanied just by a guitar. It’s heartfelt, it’s straight forward, and ultimately, mundane. When it’s done straight, it sounds like any other sad song played by any other sad girl. There’s nothing about this cover that makes it interesting to me.

So, if you, dear reader, want to cover a song and publish it on YouTube, please make it interesting. Make it unique. This is an extension of one of the best pieces of advice I’ve ever heard for being creative. When making anything, make it your own.

There’s always going to be someone who’s better than you at what you want to do. Get used to that. But no one will be better at YOU. No one will write a better you story, no one will sing your voice better. As long as your being yourself, you can’t be out done. If you can’t do better or give more, then may be you should reconsider what you’re doing.

Tagged , , , , ,

My Steampunk Problem

I like the idea of Retro-Futurism. It’s just fun. The technology of our time is very dear to us all. There is nothing more personal than the smartphone we put in our pocket, or the screens we stare at. But the present is boring, and the future worries us, at the very least.

The Past! That was fun, right? When we merge nostalgia, technology and pulp fiction we get awesome, genre bending worlds. All other -punks aside, the one I’m talking about right now is Steampunk. In my opinion, this subgenre is one good movie away from being mainstream. I said good movie. So that doesn’t mean The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Van Helsing, or Wild Wild West.

If you’re unfamiliar with steampunk, essentially, it’s applying Victorian-Era aesthetics to modern day technology. Of course it gets deeper than that, but I don’t think I’m doing it a disservice at all by describing it that way. Yet, therein lies my problem with it.

Victorian” refers mainly to England, when the empire was under Queen Victoria’s rule in the late 19th century. It was the very peak of the Crown’s power over the rest of the world. The United states was recovering from a bloody civil war and hadn’t secured its place as a global power yet. The industrial revolution would not happen until after the turn of the century.

Despite those facts, SteamPunks are many amongst geeks here in the states, and elsewhere. Go to any Con’ and see how many leather corsets, goggles, and little hats you see. They might be pirates, adventurers, aristocrats, whatever. Take a look at what’s popular amongst YA fiction. Watch Felicia Day’s YouTube channel, tell me she’s not influenced.

Do you see the disconnect I have? I’m being all hipster-y about it. I really don’t care how much exposure it’s getting, beyond my already standing problems. If you haven’t caught it, this genre is, for the most part,  inherently Euro-Centric, make that Anglo-Centric. I am of Mexican/Spanish heritage. See it yet?

I’m not accusing steampunk or fans of as being racist. Don’t get me wrong. Of course I understand that nationalism has nothing to do with liking the look, or enjoying the stories. What I’m saying is I have a problem personally identifying with a genre that has very little to do with my own heritage, and in turn, part of my identity.

It’s the same problem I have with Tolkienesque fantasy. Those stories are all derived from the history and folklore of Western Europe. I’ll talk more about that on another day.

I don’t have this problem with Dieselpunk, which takes aesthetics from the time after the Industrial Revolution (Art Deco, BioShock, Sky Captain and The World of Tomorrow). I can say that, as it’s very based in American history, which I identify with more, being a third-generation American (my grandparents were born in Colorado and Nebraska).

I must say here, that I’m not saying I don’t like this genre, I just can’t connect with it like so many of the fans I see. I’m not complaining as much as stating a point.

I know for a fact that I’m not the only one of my kind with this problem. I direct your attention to this awesome article I found on the blog The basic gist is that many Chicano/Latino/Hispanic people who want to claim fandom of Steampunk take aesthetics of what was going on in our history, instead of Anglo history: The Mexican Revolution.

This was no insignificant event. Some history, from the article:

The independence of Mexico triggered the independence of eight different countries. After the fall of the first Mexican Empire, Guatemala, Belize, Honduras, El Salvador, Costa Rica, Nicaragua, and the republics of Yucatan and Chiapas, which later were re-annexed to the Republic of Mexico, declared independence. The Republic also still retained the territories of Texas, New Mexico, and southern California.

So, for my little conundrum, following in the footsteps of others might help:

Interestingly, it is this point in history that many Mexicans use as basis for its aesthetics and steampunk characters. This later time period that we know of as the Mexican Revolution in the early twentieth century also acted like a late call to join the spirit of technological renovation and industrialization that had been held by the European powers. The Mexicans of the late nineteenth century conceived many elements of progress and technological heritage from the French, who were a major presence in the country’s development during this century. Both the fashion and lifestyle, cuisine, style of education, politics, economics, and technology came from the French style.

But here’s where I make all this for naught: I don’t care. Steampunk is huge right now, and I can only see it getting bigger. Like I said, one good movie, most likely in the next year, would solidify it’s popularity for the time being. All the purists will hate it for stupid reasons, while everyone else will enjoy wearing their little hats. As for me? I’m going to watch from the sidelines.

Though I have found my entry point, what I’m saying is that I don’t need it, want it, care for it. Again, I have no problems with the stories, the fans, the aesthetics. It’s just not for me. I think it’s because it’s looking to the past. I’ve never been one for nostalgia, especially nostalgia of a time I’ve never experienced. And it’s always confused me why the Victorian era appeals so much to women. It’s so easy for them to forget how little freedom women had at that time. Maybe it’s empowering to erase that fact from current retro futurism. Just as it’s easy for people of other heritages who don’t share direct heritage with English descendants.

I hate to just chalk up everything that people like about it to a “look.” I understand how cool things look when it’s all wood and leather and steam powered. The anachronism of a steampunk Iron Man suit is intriguing confusing and exciting all at once. But without the connection that comes from heritage of any sort, I’m left confused and hoping there’s more. For the sake of how I see the fans, more than just “it looks cool.”

Tagged , , , , , , , ,